Although his mission was not successful, Nathan Hale has been widely regarded as an American hero for being the first spy in American history and one of the first Americans to be executed for espionage. His last words, “I only regret that I have but one life to lose for my country” indicate his deep devotion to his fledgling nation and have been an inspiration to subsequent generations of Americans. Although many of the details of his mission and life remain a mystery, there are certain commonalities that can be found in all of the accounts.
In September of 1776, Nathan Hale was a 21 year old captain in the Continental Army. When there was a need for intelligence gathering following the American loss of Long Island, Hale volunteered to cross enemy lines and gather as much information about the British army in New Work as he could. To do that, he disguised himself as a Dutch schoolteacher and made his way to New York from Norwalk, Connecticut.
His activities upon arriving at New York remain something of a mystery. It is known that he took notes and made some drawings before attempting to leave the island. Before he could do that, however, he was betrayed. How he was betrayed remains a mystery as well. There are two main accounts of how this happened. One says that one of Hale’s relatives, Samuel Hale, turned him in after recognizing him in a tavern. The other says that Robert Rogers, a loyalist hero of the French and Indian war, did not believe that Hale was a schoolteacher and that he got Hale to admit he was a spy by pretending to be a spy himself. However it happened, Hale was captured on September 21, 1776.
When he was captured, the British found the notes and drawings that Hale had produced. Armed with this evidence, they easily obtained his confession that he was indeed a member of the Continental army. This made him an uninformed enemy combatant behind enemy lines. Given the rules of war at the time, the British were perfectly justified in hanging him the next morning without a trial. Before being executed, Hale is reported to have said that his only regret was that he had only one life to lose for his country. After saying those memorable words, Hale was executed at the tender age of 21.
Some have said that Hale’s mission was virtually doomed from the start. Although Hale was supposedly a hansom man, he could be easily identified by distinctive powder burns. Furthermore, he was of such a character that duplicity did not come easy for him. Given that the ability to lie convincingly is an important skill for spies to have, this was a serious flaw. Even if he had been able to play his schoolteacher role a bit better, it would have been difficult for him to obtain any real measure of success because he did not have any contacts in the city or any other spies to help him. He was completely on his own and would have had to return to the American lines before his intelligence could have been put to any use.
